What should a small business post on Facebook?
I counted the response to 5,129 posts from my family workshop's Facebook page. Here is what drew the most response, what drew the least, and how to use it in your own business.
Where the figures come from
Berrima Diesel Service is my family's business, and I am its marketing manager. Its Facebook page has more than 140,000 followers. In November 2026 I counted the likes, comments and shares on 5,129 of its posts, from May 2010 to June 2026.
To keep the comparison fair, I measured each post against an ordinary post from the same year. So "2 times" in the tables below means that kind of post drew twice the likes, comments and shares of an ordinary post that year.
What drew more response
| Kind of post | Posts counted | Response compared with an ordinary post |
|---|---|---|
| Myth against fact ("the truth about...") | 64 | 2.18 times |
| Bad workmanship or a failed part, shown | 217 | 1.89 times |
| Asking the audience, such as "what is this?" | 89 | 1.87 times |
| Video | 1,333 | 1.66 times |
| Explaining how or why | 387 | 1.62 times |
| A first-hand story ("we had one in last week") | 233 | 1.47 times |
What drew less
| Kind of post | Posts counted | Response compared with an ordinary post |
|---|---|---|
| One photo | 1,990 | 0.88 times |
| Sale or offer wording | 449 | 0.79 times |
| A link to another website | 378 | 0.74 times |
| A post shared from another page | 169 | 0.40 times |
Three things that surprised me
- Longer posts did not do worse. The weakest posts were the short ones, 61 to 140 characters. Posts over 1,500 characters drew the most.
- The day and the time made no real difference. No day of the week and no time of day stood out.
- A few posts do the heavy lifting. The best tenth of posts drew about half of all the response. You cannot tell in advance which post will be the big one, which is why turning up every week matters.
What the best posts have in common
I read the 45 strongest posts one by one. They share a shape:
- They open on a real problem, and often name who has it: a model, an engine, a fault.
- They show something real, such as the failed part on the bench.
- They take a side and say what to do, in the business's own voice.
- Many put a dollar figure on the wrong advice and on the fix.
What to do with this in your business
- Show the work behind the counter. People want to see what you really do.
- When you hear the same wrong idea from customers again and again, write a post that sets it straight.
- Use video when you can, and write a few sentences to go with it.
- Ask a real question now and then.
- Keep the selling posts few.
- Keep turning up. For ten years this page posted between 5 and 13 times a week.
How I use this for the businesses I work with
This is the thinking behind the advice I give every business I take on: what to show, what to explain, and what to leave out. I advise you on the content that suits your business, the posts are prepared for you each week, and nothing goes out until you approve it.
Want this done for your business?
I run a managed social media posting service for small local businesses. Each week you get one sheet of posts, you approve the ones you want, and only those go out. See how it works, or get in touch.